Q: If the 4th Amendment protects us from illegal search and seizure, then how to they justify random DOT inspections?
A: This one is easy and one question that is asked many times. Well the answer is actually much more involved but I thought I should keep it simple.
The Federal government authorizes commercial vehicles (U.S. Supreme Court decision) and the Fourth Amendment does not apply for the following reason.
The vehicle inspection is based on a transportation safety requirement. When a commercial vehicle owner or operator applies and receives the Federal DOT permits and authorization to operate intrastate or interstate, permission for the safety inspection is implied.
A vehicle inspection is not a search for contraband items, wanted persons or other illegal activity involving a motor vehicle, therefore not a constitutional violation.
The inspection only involves the checking of required equipment and the checking of other documents that must be carried on the driver and in the vehicle by law.
A: This one is easy and one question that is asked many times. Well the answer is actually much more involved but I thought I should keep it simple.
The Federal government authorizes commercial vehicles (U.S. Supreme Court decision) and the Fourth Amendment does not apply for the following reason.
The vehicle inspection is based on a transportation safety requirement. When a commercial vehicle owner or operator applies and receives the Federal DOT permits and authorization to operate intrastate or interstate, permission for the safety inspection is implied.
A vehicle inspection is not a search for contraband items, wanted persons or other illegal activity involving a motor vehicle, therefore not a constitutional violation.
The inspection only involves the checking of required equipment and the checking of other documents that must be carried on the driver and in the vehicle by law.
RSS Feed